Case Reports

UPC Case Reports

Coffee machine litigation leads to early defeat for patentee
28 November 2023
CUP&CINO Kaffeesystem-Vertrieb GmbH & Co. KG v ALPINA COFFEE SYSTEMS GmbH, Order of 13 September 2023[1] In a case before the Vienna Local Division, the patent holder, CUP&CINO Kaffeesystem-Vertrieb...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
#
Opt out
#
Provisional injunction
Milan Local Division Grants Inspection Order
24 November 2023
The Milan Local Division has granted an inspection order[1] pursuant to Rules 192-199 RoP, the first order granted by the UPC allowing inspection of a defendant's premises.
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Confidentiality
#
Evidence (general)
#
Preservation of evidence
Lessons from Harvard: UK-based Nanostring ordered to pay EUR 300,000 as security for legal costs in revocation action
03 November 2023
NanoString Technologies Europe Limited v President and Fellows of Harvard College (UPC_CFI_252/2023) Decision delivered on 30 October 2023 (Order no.
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Security for costs
Should the language of proceedings be changed: balancing the interests of the parties
02 November 2023
Plant-e Knowledge B.V. & Plant-e B.V. v Arkyne Technologies S.L. Order of 18 October 2023 (ORD_581189/2023) The claimants, two Netherlands companies, ("Plant-e") launched an infringement action on 12...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Language
Opt-out Withdrawal Ineffective: Choices have Consequences!
31 October 2023
AIM Sport Vision AG v Supponor Oy & Others (UPC_CFI_214/2023) Decision of 20 October 2023 (ORD_572699/2023 and ORD_5821/2023) Facts & Main Arguments These proceedings before the Unified Patent Court...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
#
Jurisdiction
#
Opt out
First penalty payment in a UPC case
30 October 2023
myStromer AG v Revolt Zycling AG Düsseldorf Local Division Order of 18 October (ORD_526778/ 2023)[1] Following its first ex parte provisional injunction[2], the UPC (Düsseldorf Local Division)...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Penalty payment
UPC grants access to pleadings for the first time
25 October 2023
Ocado Innovation Limited v Autostore AS & Others – Order of 17 October 2023 (ORD 543819/2023) In September we reported on two judgments by Munich Central Division refusing requests for access to...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Access to documents
CFI clarifies scope for preliminary objections
23 October 2023
Order ORD_576853/2023 [1] dated 29 Sept 2023 by Local Chamber Munich (Presiding Judge and Rapporteur Mr. Zigann) in the case Edwards Lifesciences Corp. vs. Meril GmbH and Meril Life Sciences Pvt. Ltd.
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Jurisdiction
#
Other procedural aspects
#
Security for costs
First appeal decision from the UPC
19 October 2023
Amgen Inc v Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH & Ors Order of 13 October 2023 (Order ref ORD_580110/2023) [1] Both Amgen and Sanofi-Aventis appealed an order [2] in which an extension of the deadline...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Appeal
#
Other procedural aspects
#
Service of actions
Jozef Frans Nelissen v OrthoApnea S.L. Order of 21 September 2023
18 October 2023
The UPC has published its third decision to preserve evidence (following the related Orders of 13 and 14 June 2023 in Oerlikon Textile GMBH & CO KG v Himson Engineering Private Limited and v Bhagat...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Preservation of evidence
10x Genomics not successful second time around
12 October 2023
On the same day that the decision granting 10x Genomics a provisional injunction against NanoString on the basis of the unitary patent EP4108782 was announced (19 September 2023), there also took...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
#
Jurisdiction
#
Provisional injunction
Termination of Proceedings
03 October 2023
Ocado Innovation Limited v. Autostore AS Order of 11 September 2023[1] (Order ref ORD_571090/2023) Ocado filed an infringement action against Autostore on 2 June 2023 in the Milan local division.
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Costs
#
Withdrawal of an action
Determining Date of Service and Corresponding Time limits
28 September 2023
Amgen Inc v Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH & Ors Order of 29 August 2023 (Order ref ORD_566193/2023)[1] This case arises from a difference of date of service on multiple defendants, and thus raises...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Other procedural aspects
#
Service of actions
#
Time limits
Injunction granted in 10x Genomics v NanoString
27 September 2023
The UPC Local Division in Munich handed down a decision on 19 September 2023 following a hearing over two days on 5/6 September 2023, granting a provisional injunction against NanoString to restrain...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
#
Inventive step
#
Novelty
When can third parties obtain access to written pleadings and evidence at UPC?
22 September 2023
A judge of the Central court in Munich has recently considered a request by a third party for access to written pleadings and evidence under Rule 262.1(b) in two cases.
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Access to documents

Other Case Reports

IPKat: Ruling in Generics (t/a Mylan) v Yeda and Teva
11 July 2012
Today’s ruling by Mr Justice Arnold (Patents Court, England and Wales) in Generics (t/a Mylan) v Yeda and Teva has been summarised by Darren Smyth for the IPKat.
#
Litigation
#
Life
Samsung victorious in dispute with Apple over tablet computers
09 July 2012
Samsung has won a longstanding battle with Apple concerning one of Apple's Registered Community Designs for its tablet computers.The decision is significant because it represents the first...
#
Litigation
#
Digital
Confidential Information, In house lawyers and former employees – who has the burden of proof?
05 July 2012
Generics (UK) Ltd v Yeda Research & Development Co Ltd & Teva Pharmaceutical Industries[2012] EWCA Civ 726The Court of Appeal has overturned an injunction that prevented an in-house patent attorney...
#
Litigation
#
Life
Darren Smyth's time as IPKat guest blogger comes to an end
02 July 2012
Partner Darren Smyth's role as one of the IPKat's guest bloggers has come to a conclusion after six months.He will continue to post intermittently to the IPKat and more regularly to his Blog on EIP...
#
Elements
IPO seeks views on helping SMEs get value from their IP
25 June 2012
The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) is seeking comments on its proposals to offer support to SMEs to maximise the value of their IP assets.
#
Patent Strategy
Apple v Samsung tablet design case latest
20 June 2012
The litigation between Apple and Samsung about tablet computers and the alleged infringement of a (Community) Registered Design has been taking place in the High Court this week.
#
Digital
#
Building a Resilient Quantum Patent Portfolio: Winning the Race to File First
23andMe's first patent causes a rift with customers
19 June 2012
A recent IPKat post by Darren Smyth highlights the adverse consumer reaction to the issuance of a patent to a US company 23andMe which offers to sequence your genome and tell you about its...
#
Life
Referrals to the Enlarged Board of Appeal over procedural matters: a good use of EBA resources?
18 June 2012
In a recent IPKat post, Darren Smyth ponders whether the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office should be referring cases to the Enlarged Board of Appeal on matters of procedural...
#
Elements
Smith & Nephew v Convatec Technologies
15 June 2012
Darren's Smyth's latest IPKat post concerns an action by Smith & Nephew to revoke a patent owned by Convatec Technologies for antimicrobial wound dressings impregnated with silver.
#
Elements
'Tomato' patent case at the EPO results in second referral to the Enlarged Board
07 June 2012
The European Patent Office (EPO) has referred a case relating to dried tomatoes to the Enlarged Board of Appeal for a second time.In his latest IPKat post, EIP's Darren Smyth discusses the most...
#
Elements
Comic Enterprises Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp [2012] EWPCC 13 – guidance on litigation before the Patents County Court
20 April 2012
In ruling on an application to transfer a passing off and trade mark infringement action from the Patents County Court (PCC) to the High Court, HHJ Birss QC has provided further useful guidance for...
#
Litigation
Registered Community Designs: reasons for refusal
19 April 2012
The OHIM has begun publishing information about Registered Community Design applications that have been refused.The designs themselves are not shown, but the grounds for refusal are now being made...
#
Building a Resilient Quantum Patent Portfolio: Winning the Race to File First
Sanofi-Aventis patents on cancer drug Taxotere declared invalid
11 April 2012
Two Sanofi-Aventis US patents for the cancer drug docetaxel, marketed as Taxotere, have been declared invalid by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
#
Litigation
#
Life
Samsung v Apple tablet battle hits the UK
05 April 2012
The ongoing dispute between Apple and Samsung over Apple's Registered Community Designs for its iPad has now entered the UK courts.Darren Smyth's latest IPKat post relates to a decision of Mr Justice...
#
Digital
#
Building a Resilient Quantum Patent Portfolio: Winning the Race to File First
Poland's law on cheap drugs declared contrary to EU law
03 April 2012
A Polish law which allowed the sale of unapproved drugs which were cheaper than those approved has been declared contrary to EU law.The decision by the Court of Justice of the European Union is...
#
Life
No results found.
There are no results with this criteria. Try changing your search.
Stay in the Know

The UPC Newsletter

Get expert insights and the top patent stories delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.