Ericsson sued ASUS and its logistics provider Arvato, inter alia, for infringement of EP 2 727 342, which Ericsson considered essential for the HEVC/H.265 standard. The patent concerns reference-picture signalling. By decision of 6 November 2026 (“Decision”), the Milan Local Division (“Court”) held the patent valid and found indirect infringement by ASUS products incorporating Intel or AMD hardware acceleration for HEVC decoding.
The Court also held that Ericsson occupied a dominant position in the relevant market. The central issue was therefore whether Ericsson had complied with its FRAND obligations and followed the negotiation sequence set out by the CJEU in Huawei v ZTE before seeking, inter alia, an injunction.
ASUS's FRAND defence was successful. The Court refused the requested injunction, recall and destruction, but granted a declaration of indirect infringement, found ASUS liable for damages, and ordered ASUS and Arvato to provide information and render accounts.
The Court characterised the infringement notice as the first step in the Huawei v ZTE framework. It adopted the approach suggested by the European Commission (which was initially filed in a national German case in 2024 between different parties) assuming that all steps under the Huawei v ZTE framework are strictly sequential and must be complied with chronologically. According to the Court, it is decisive that this first step is fulfilled before commencing proceedings seeking FRAND-encumbered requests, as this is the point when the claimant loses control over the commencement, i.e. when the Statement of Claim is lodged and service is passed to the Registry.
The Court ruled that requesting only a conditional injunction, which would only be granted after the implementer/defendant had further time after the Statement of Claim was filed to accept claimant’s offer, did not change this requirement. Further, any shortcomings could not be remedied at the same time as, or after commencing, proceedings where, inter alia, an injunction is requested. The purpose of the infringement notice is to give a willing implementer sufficient time to genuinely express their willingness and enter into negotiations without the threat embodied in proceedings for injunctive relief.
The Court set out that for a valid infringement notice, the SEP owner must inform the implementer of the alleged infringement, identify the patent concerned, and specify how it is allegedly infringed. The information must be sufficient for the implementer to understand and assess the allegation before deciding whether to enter into a licence agreement. However, the Court has not set out the specific material requirements that are needed for the information to be sufficient.
The Court found that, before filing the Statement of Claim on 14 June 2024, Ericsson had neither identified the patent nor explained the alleged manner of infringement. The Court further established that Ericsson had not initiated concrete licensing negotiations with the defendants concerning its HEVC SEPs. According to the Decision, the negotiations dated back to 2003 which, at least recently, were about a cross-license. However, the Court found that Ericsson supplied the material concerning the infringement notice only on the filing date and attempted to remedy this by making its injunction request conditional on ASUS not accepting Ericsson's proposed licence by a later deadline.
As parts of the Decision are redacted, it is not clear what information Ericsson did provide before filing the Statement of Claim and, why specifically the Court found the information not to be sufficient to constitute an infringement notice. However, the Court did state that a reference to the publicly accessible ITU registers (where, unlike with ETSI, the FRAND declarations are not made on a patent family basis but in general) is not sufficient for an infringement notice.
The Court rejected Ericsson’s argument that an infringement notice would have not been necessary anyway because its UPC proceedings were merely defensive in light of US litigation initiated against Ericsson in 2023. The Court was also not convinced by Ericsson’s assertion that ASUS acted as an unwilling licensee during negotiations.
The Decision adopts a more formal and sequential approach than earlier UPC decisions. More specifically, the Mannheim Local Division (decision of 22 November 2024, UPC_CFI_210/2023 – Panasonic v OPPO) and the Munich Local Division (decision of 18 December 2024, UPC_CFI_9/2023 – Huawei v Netgear) each rejected the strictly sequential approach suggested by the EU Commission.
Instead, Mannheim and Munich allowed for greater flexibility and decided that the requirements for an infringement notice should not be too strict and formalistic, especially, when it comes to larger portfolios.
This Decision of the Milan Local Division shows that there can be material differences in the still developing case law of the UPC, even concerning questions that seemed to have been answered by several Local Divisions before. The selection of the forum, also at the UPC, therefore remains an important strategic consideration.
More specifically, this case shows that it is important for SEP owners to pay attention to potential formal obligations, even in scenarios where there is not much time to prepare the proceedings. Preparing and establishing a general practice in advance that balances formal considerations and practicality is therefore recommended.