Case Reports

UPC Case Reports

Extension of time limit for statement of defence
20 September 2023
Edwards Lifesciences Corporation v. Meril GmbH and Meril Life Sciences Pvt Ltd. Order of 23 August 2023 Edwards Lifesciences Corporation (Claimant in the main action) is the proprietor of EP3646825,...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Time limits
Who is first to file?
15 September 2023
Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH & Others v Amgen Inc - Order of 24 August 2023 Background On the opening day of UPC, 1 June 2023, Amgen sued Sanofi for infringement of EP 3,666,797 in the Munich...
#
UPC
#
Analysis
First to file at the UPC
15 September 2023
Sanofi-Aventis Deutschland GmbH & Others v Amgen Inc - Order of 24 August 2023 Background On the opening day of UPC, 1 June 2023, Amgen sued Sanofi for infringement of EP 3,666,797 in the Munich...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Jurisdiction
#
Other procedural aspects
Terminology at the Unified Patent Court
12 September 2023
The UPC is a new legal system, and it is not to be expected that its terminology should follow any single national system. When we look at the UPC Agreement itself, and the Rules of Procedure and the...
#
UPC
#
Analysis
UPC Exceptionally grants extension of time limit for preliminary objection
04 September 2023
Edwards Lifesciences Corporation v. Meril GmbH and Meril Life Sciences Pvt Ltd. Order of 1 August 2023 Edwards Lifesciences Corporation (Claimant in the main action) is the proprietor of EP3646825,...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Time limits
Provisional Injunction granted by the Unified Patent Court
29 August 2023
myStromer AG v Revolt Zycling AG, Order of 22 June 2023 and Order of 30 June 2023 [1] The UPC - Düsseldorf Local Division - has issued its first ex parte provisional injunction only recently...
#
UPC
Orders to Preserve Evidence granted by the Unified Patent Court
22 August 2023
Oerlikon Textile GMBH & CO KG v Himson Engineering Private Limited, Order of 13 June 2023 Oerlikon Textile GMBH & CO KG v Bhagat Group, Order of 14 June 2023 Just two weeks after the Unified Patent...
#
UPC
#
Recent cases
#
Preservation of evidence
Early statistics regarding interest in unitary patent protection
04 August 2023
The EPO has recently added ‘Requests for unitary effect' to its Statistics & Trends Centre. The Statistics & Trends Centre provides a dashboard that now gives information about requests for unitary...
#
UPC
UPCA - Harmonisation of Infringement
05 July 2023
Over a decade ago, in 2013, when I was writing for the IPKat, I wrote a post opining that the UPC Agreement should produce a harmonisation of the substantive law of patent infringement across...
#
UPC
#
Analysis
Update on Unitary Patent request filing statistics
14 June 2023
The first batch of unitary patents was registered this week. According to the European Patent Register, 609 requests for unitary effect have been allowed and published on Monday 12 June 2023.
#
UPC
Unitary Patent Day 2023
07 June 2023
Today is Unitary Patent day!In principle, a Unitary Patent could be obtained for a European Patent granted from 1 June 2023. But in practice, the European Patent Office only publishes grant of...
#
UPC
The UPC is now open!
01 June 2023
After more than 50 years in the making, the Unified Patent Court finally launches today – 1 June 2023. This represents the most significant development in European patent law and practice since the...
#
UPC
The UPC: I've done nothing about it - will it be okay?
31 May 2023
Owners of EP applications and patents will have almost certainly have had requests by now asking whether they wish to opt their patents/applications out of the jurisdiction of the UPC.
#
UPC
#
Analysis
The limits of an “opt-in” to the UPC – How and when can national actions block the way back to the UPC?
30 May 2023
Key points: OPT-OUT / OPT-IN / Art. 83 UPCA / TRANSITIONAL REGIMEImmediately prior to the launch of the UPC, there is heated debate among patent owners as to whether or not to declare an "opt-out"...
#
UPC
#
Analysis
EIP Amar webinar - Prepare for the UP and UPC
16 May 2023
On 21 and 22 March a panel from EIP Latest hosted an informative webinar where they discussed everything your business needs to know about the effect of the incoming Unitary Patent and Unified Patent...
#
UPC
#
Analysis

Other Case Reports

Incomplete secondary evidence pleaded late in proceedings has no chance against prima facie obviousness in High Court decision
25 November 2024
A 163-page judgment for Pfizer Limited v. GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals S.A. & Anor [2024] EWHC 2523 was handed down on 7 October 2024 by Mr Justice Mellor.
#
Litigation
Munich Local Division issues the first decision by default in an infringement proceeding as Defendant does not respond to Statement of Claim
14 October 2024
i-mop GmbH v ARCORA International GmbH (UPC_CFI_193/2024) Order dated 11 October 2024 (ORD_47439/2024) concerning EP 3 760 094 B1 The patent in suit EP 3 760 094 B1 relates to a floor cleaning device.
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
T 1741/22 - no credible technical effect produced by deriving additional data from medical measurements
19 September 2024
An interesting "B" decision from Board 3.5.05 was published yesterday relating to the generation of new data from medical measurements being relied on for a technical effect.
#
EPO
A Late Challenge: PI refused for alleged VAR infringement
10 September 2024
Ballinno B.V. v UEFA, Kinexon GmbH and Kinexon Sports & Media GmbH UPC_CFI_151/2024 Order of 3 June 2024 ORD_39782/2024[1] Whilst thoughts of Euro '24 may be starting to slip into the past...
#
Recent cases
#
Infringement
#
Provisional injunction
No Country for New Laws
22 July 2024
Trailblazing developments in Artificial Intelligence have left a litany of complex legal cases in their wake, and judges are tasked with deciding how old law should be interpreted against the...
#
Codiphy
#
Digital
€325 million Funding for Semiconductor Research and Innovation in the UK and the EU
09 July 2024
Europe's Chips Joint Undertaking has bolstered its support for the semiconductor industry by announcing three funding calls with a combined value of up to €325M.
#
Ampliphy
#
Digital
#
Patenting
An Ocean Apart – Differences in US and EPO claim interpretation
04 June 2024
Recent cases from the US Federal Circuit and the EPO Boards of Appeal highlight how the two jurisdictions have reached strict, and completely opposite, approaches to interpreting claims in light of...
No items found.
Court of Appeal affirms death of Bayer’s blood clotting patent in expedited hearing
03 June 2024
The Court of Appeal announced at the conclusion of the hearing, on 16 May 2024, that Bayer's appeal in the rivaroxaban litigation against a finding of invalidity following challenges by a number of...
#
Litigation
T 0192/22 - Is a first medical use claim a magic bullet?
31 May 2024
The EIP team was pleased to receive the BoA Decision on T 0197/22 earlier this month, providing the reasons for revocation of Translate Bio's EP 3318248 B1 at the oral proceedings held in March,...
#
Oppositions
#
Life
#
Patenting
T 1762/21 – The EPO Board of Appeal Clarifies the Term “Inextricably Linked” When Assessing an Intermediate Generalisation
24 May 2024
A recent decision from a Technical Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office provides clarity as to how "intermediate generalisations" are assessed for added matter.
#
EPO
Updated EPO Guidelines on AI – why US companies should encourage close collaboration between their US and European attorneys on AI patent applications
20 May 2024
On 1 March 2024, the European Patent Office (EPO) updated its Guidelines for Examination regarding AI inventions. This included new wording relating to the sufficient disclosure of training data.
#
Codiphy
Court of Appeal takes AIM at attempts to show knock-on effect of pragmatic case management
15 May 2024
Supponor Ltd v AIM Sport Development AG [2024] EWCA Civ 396 In a judgment handed down on 23 April 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed Supponor's appeal against the decision of Meade J in the High...
#
Litigation
Blood drains from Bayer patent as it is found to be non-inventive
07 May 2024
We previously reported on Bayer's application seeking an interim injunction against a number of generics companies to protect its rivaroxaban product (link) ahead of the imminent judgment on validity...
#
Litigation
To Injunct Or Not To Injunct?
10 April 2024
Judge Asked To Grant A 9/10 Day Interim Injunction to Protect Bayer's Anticoagulant Rivaroxaban Ahead of Main Judgment Pharmaceutical company, Bayer found success in its application seeking an...
#
Litigation
Balancing Expertise: Mellor J's Ruling on Scientific Advisers vs. Expert Evidence
21 March 2024
Hill v Touchlight Genetics Ltd & Ors [2024] EWHC 533 (Pat) (08 March 2024) Summary This judgment concerns a novel issue in the Patents Court which arose at the second CMC in this action, regarding...
#
Litigation
No results found.
There are no results with this criteria. Try changing your search.
Stay in the Know

The UPC Newsletter

Get expert insights and the top patent stories delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.